Faith Integrative Therapy & EMDR in Colorado Springs
A long long time ago… in a city far away…. I had a weird experience integrating faith and mental health.
I was a member at a church where a client of mine also attended.
One Monday, this client called me and told me the Sunday before, during an altar call, one of the pastors on staff, in prayer, warned against me being too “humanistic” in my approach to therapy and suggested switching to a different therapist.
As this pastor knew me, although not well, it felt deeply personal. I felt wildly misunderstood, hurt, defensive, and “not Christian enough.” I didn’t even know what to say. I knew how important my own faith was to me, and how thoughtfully I approached the integration of faith and therapy - whether a client was strong in their faith, questioning their faith, or not interested in faith (often because of past religious trauma).
And yet, I was publicly questioned for something deeply and personally important and meaningful to me.
For all of you who have had weird, or painful, or shaming experiences at church… I see you.
It took me a while to reconcile why I may be seen this way when I knew it wasn’t the truth about me. And over time, I found some language for what may be causing the disconnect.
Physical Life vs Spiritual Life
So first, I’ll be straightforward that I am not by training a Christian counselor. I am extensively trained as a mental health professional. As a Christian person, I always say I speak the language, understand the foundations, have likely had similar religious experiences, and can decide together with clients how this fits into our overall treatment plan.
For some of my clients, faith is a positive resource that offers great comfort and guidance, and incorporating it strengthens the work we do together. For others, faith is more complicated - maybe connected to a negative event that caused pain, or an experience that was traumatic - and then we decide together how to incorporate or address it, if at all.
But in learning so much about psychology, neuroscience, and the nervous system over the years, here is something I’ve come to understand…
From a Christian perspective, we have a physical life in addition to a spiritual life - and God created both.
Understanding the brain, body, and nervous system is not anti-Christian - outside of the science, it is also understanding a design we were created with innately, how it can get out of balance, and how that balance can be restored.
We seem to understand this intuitively about physical health, but struggle to apply the same principles to mental health.
Most of us would not tell someone who wanted to lose weight or make their body healthier to just pray and read their Bible more. We would likely recognize their spiritual life may be a great resource and support for them in their physical health journey, but they would also need to apply practical principles - like a plan for food and exercise.
Yet when it comes to mental health, we can have difficulty understanding that the same concepts apply. The number of Christian people I’ve sat with who were buckling under the weight of shame and condemnation from having been told by other Christians that they’re just not praying enough, or having enough faith, and that’s the cause of their anxiety or mental health struggles, breaks my heart.
When I show them what actually might be happening, that their brain and body may be doing something they’re designed to do, just out of balance from the intention of the design, there’s so much relief. And when we start to address those physical life, practical pieces alongside the spiritual disciplines they’re relying on - things get better. And usually, quickly.
I think we get confused because there is an incredible overlap between spiritual and physical principles when it comes to mental health. In my opinion and experience, addressing the physical life component of mental health care in addition to the spiritual is not “humanistic” - it is comprehensive.
What does faith-integrative therapy look like?
In therapy, we'll look together at a whole-person view of your health, incorporating mind, body, and spirit. That might mean drawing on faith as a source of strength, exploring how spiritual beliefs affect the way you understand yourself, or making room for questions, anger, doubt, or painful religious experiences. It can also mean leaving faith entirely outside the therapy room if that is what you want.
I have worked with so many people who needed to take a step back from their faith, or had never been able to really connect with faith, because of painful experiences and trauma. I will always honor that. For me, this is not anti-Christian - it is basic respect for where someone is at in their own process of healing without imposing a particular set of views and beliefs.
Therapy doesn’t have to be at odds with faith
I wish I'd had this language all those years ago when I was told that the way I practiced therapy was somehow “too humanistic.” I probably still would have felt hurt, but I would have understood the disconnect differently.
I don't believe caring for the brain, body, and nervous system diminishes the importance of spiritual life. I believe we can make room for both.
If your faith is an important part of who you are, there should be room for it in therapy. If faith has become complicated, painful, or confusing, there should be room for that too. And if you've been told that struggling with anxiety, trauma, or your mental health means you aren't praying enough, believing enough, or trusting God enough, I hope you hear this:
Needing help with your mental health is not evidence of a failure of faith.
Sometimes healing means tending to the whole person - brain, body, relationships, experiences, and spirit.